More American Idol

Feb 5 2010 01:48 PM ET

'American Idol' source on Howard Stern rumors: The search for Simon Cowell's replacement 'has just begun'

While the blogosphere is atwitter today over a New York Post report that American Idol has tapped radio jock Howard Stern as the leading candidate Read the full post.

Comments (325 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 14
  • Jim

    If people are saying they won’t watch if Howard becomes a judge then hopefully he BECOMES A JUDGE. The only people who ever watch Idol are preppy teenyboppers who spend their lunch break pathetically putting on makeup in the bathroom…

  • Jade UK

    I’m from the UK so don’t know Howard Stern all that well but doesn’t he swear like all of the time? I can’t see why they’d want him on a family TV show.

  • Jonny

    I like Howard Stern, but I would NOT like him on Idol. His ego and personality would take over; it would be a completely different show. Love his radio show, but putting him on Idol would be a bad idea.

  • dave

    Nope
    Fri 02/05/10 3:31 PM

    We had Stern on the air here (Detroit) for a few years. I listened. Not that funny. Of course, i don’t care about American Idol, either, so that’s that.

    So then why comment dumbass

  • dave

    hmmmm I think it should be a really mean gay man…. or a drag queen…. who else could come up with such witty remarks?
    – of course they could go with someone who has just as much power in the record industry like Clive Davis…. or the So you think you can dance judge, Nigel.

  • dave

    ELTON JOHN would be perfect!

  • Correct Me If I’m Wrong…

    but didn’t Howard Stern invent – or was, at least, a very heavy promoter of – Vote For The Worst, that website that encouraged people to deliberately vote for the least talented contestants on AI to untimately produce the worst winner possible?

  • JaySin420

    Howard Stern from 10 years ago would have kicked his older self’s ass just for being involved in this discussion.

  • jb

    What an utter waste of Stern’s time and talent that would be. Thankfully it will never happen.

  • Iris

    If Howard’s in, I’m out.

  • rooster

    Replace with all new cast Me, Gloria Estaban and Bill Medley. That will work.

  • LuckyD

    AI has always been a family show. If they ever get Howard Stern, they’ll also have to get a censor with quick reflexes.

    • dross

      Howard Stern has been involved in broadcasting for 30 years. He is intelligent and knows what language he can use, depending on what he is broadcasting on.

  • whatevs

    I hate that man more than anything.

  • Matt

    I do not watch the show now, but I would most def start turning in if Howard was a judge.

  • Maryellen

    Stern actally came up with the idea for this show a long time ago. For those that say he would just be mean, you are just going off some preconceived nottion of what his show is like. Howard is an insightful and thoughtful entertainer. While he may discuss topics some prudes might think of as taboo, the rest of us well adjusted people think he is great.

    Personally Howard wold be the only reason I would watch this inane version of Star Search.

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 14
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP